Tag Archives: Comcast

À la carte TV

Apparently the FCC have taken a closer look at the figures they were offered to prove that à la carte programming would increase prices. Turns out the figures were flawed, and prices would actually drop according to the FCC’s own analysis.

Predictably, the media giants are howling with dire warnings of even bigger price hikes, mass censorship, outbreaks of bird flu, and anything else they can think of.

I’m getting tired of seeing the same old crappy arguments wheeled out time and time again, so I’ve put together a page on à la carte TV myths, based on thoughts I originally wrote up in a letter to the FCC. (Hey, they asked for comments.)

The prize for worst response has to go to Comcast, who announced yet another 4-7% price hike a few days after the FCC turnaround.

House stuff

Time Warner turned up yesterday and hooked up the Internet. We now have a nice, reliable high-speed connection again. There seems to be nobody in WiFi range who has a wireless access point; either that or they’re not broadcasting SSIDs. Reception is fabulous throughout the house. The modem and router are in the office, and I have the music server up and running again.

It turned out that Time Warner have some kind of lock on their back-end systems to restrict the allowed set of MAC addresses for cable modems. If your modem isn’t on their approved list and in the MAC range their system knows about, you can’t use it. So, I now have a surplus US Robotics USR6000 cable modem. eBay time…

On the plus side, the Cable Guy tells me that RoadRunner in Austin includes the cable modem in the cost of the service, unlike Comcast who charged an extra monthly rental fee for a modem. We’ll see.

For once I don’t feel too bad about the $40 hook-up fee, as the cable guy had to string coax from pole to pole using a long metal hook and a tall ladder. He says the signal quality is great, and the download speeds certainly seem spiffy–at least 50% better than Comcast for about the same price.

Unfortunately, Time Warner aren’t so reasonable when it comes to TV. To get the essentials–Cartoon Network, Comedy Central and BBC America plus scrolling program guide–we’d have to pay $68.21 a month, plus another $10 for a DVR. Or, $64 a month and put up with decompress/compress artifacts from using the old ReplayTV.

So, we’d already decided DirecTV with TiVo was the way forward. $41.99 plus $4.99 for TiVo, but it records the MPEG stream direct from the satellite to the hard drive so there’s no quality loss, and you can record two shows at once while you watch a third show recorded earlier. Plus, all the channels are digital quality, unlike with cable.

DirecTV presents its own problems, however. To get the full channel lineup for Austin you need two pieces of coax going from the dish to the receiver, and for the TiVo option you need a phone line too.

The phone line thing wasn’t such a problem. I needed a real phone line for the home office anyway, and SBC may be Satan, but they’re cheaper than Verizon. The TiVo could call out on the office line overnight and that would be fine.

So, SBC came out. They also played the game of running wires from pole to pole. Their technician got the phone connection as far as the outside of the house, but then he hit a snag. However he wired things up outside, no phone service inside; and when he put a signal generator into one of the sockets inside, he got signal on all four wires. I’ve wired phone connections, and I know that that ain’t right–the phone signal should end up across exactly 2 wires.

I tracked down the electricians who wired the house. They came out to investigate, and discovered that whichever of their colleagues had done the job had completely botched it. No two sockets downstairs were wired up the same way. In the end, they opened up and rewired every socket. On the plus side, I found out that although the sockets are CAT-3, the wire in the walls is at least CAT-5e. So theoretically at least, I could switch the wall plates to Ethernet one day and switch the entire telephone network to VOIP.

But not today. TiVo needs a real phone line for its modem, and I want to see how reliable the Internet service is before trusting it for my phone calls.

Since the electricians were at the house anyway, I paid them to run a second coax from the living room to the nest of cables on the side of the house, plus another CAT5e phone connection for good measure. To do this they had to drill down from inside the house, because they couldn’t find exactly the right point to drill up from underneath, and obviously nobody wanted to risk drilling up through the beautiful wood floor.

So right now there’s a missing faceplate and some damage to the drywall, but I can patch that up and put in a 4-hole plate, install an RJ-11 and two coax sockets plus a blanking plate, and I’ll have a nice clean DirecTV hookup point exactly where I need it. The DirecTV installer can stick the dish on the roof, run the wires down the side of the house, and hook it all up from outside without having to drill holes in anything or run unsightly cables inside the house. Free installation sounds great, but I’ve seen what happens when free installation involves routing a cable from your living room to the outside world, and it isn’t pretty.

Could I have routed the extra coax myself? Probably, but what I really paid for was not having to spend an hour of my time doing it, and not having to crawl under the house, where there could be poisonous spiders, 6″ centipedes, snakes, or scorpions.

Router madness

My router decided to crap out. It’s an SMC. It was over $200 when I bought it, back in the mists of time, but a few years later you can pick them up for $30. Mine suddenly decided that it would be a good idea to lock up (a) every time there was an incoming SSH connection, and (b) any time I attempted to log in to change its settings or reboot it.

So I stomped off to Staples and picked up a new router. This one’s a Netgear, it was the fastest and most reliable in PC Magazine’s tests, and it happened to be on sale locally.

In a glass-half-full kind of way, I must admit that router technology has improved a lot in the last couple of years. I plugged this one in, and was rather startled when it detected the cable modem, worked out the right settings for Comcast, and just worked. I disconnected the SMC, used the iBook to configure the Netgear to have the same SSID network name the SMC used to use, and all the other Macs kept working. No reboots.

Then came Linux. That seemed more reluctant to accept change. There were probably cache files for dhcpcd that I could have found, but it was easier to reboot and have everything just work again.

Then came Windows. It seemed to be confused by the sudden loss of base station, and wouldn’t renew a DHCP lease to get a new IP address. So, I tried rebooting it. Once I did that, it decided it didn’t have a network connection at all. I tried running the wireless card control panel, which told me I had the wrong driver version installed and that I should reinstall it.

So, I downloaded the Orinoco driver software on the Mac, wrote it to a USB memory stick, transferred it to the PC, and reinstalled. The installer seemed to finish, but when I rebooted there was no change.

Next I used Add/Remove Programs to remove the Orinoco software, rebooted, and installed it again. Still no change.

Finally I removed the wireless card, rebooted, removed the software, rebooted, and plugged the card in again. Windows helpfully started installing something it had found lying around somewhere. It got as far as installing Net Firewall, and complained that the code wasn’t signed by Microsoft. I told it to go ahead anyway, and it told me that a file was missing and the install had been cancelled.

Then it started the Net Firewall install again. And again. And again.

I rebooted again, pulling the wireless card as I did so. This time no spontaneous install. I plugged in the wireless card… and wonder of wonders, it worked this time.

So, I tried running the VPN software… and that’s broken. It just goes into an infinite loop of trying to set up the connection. Tech support can’t help. I’m gonna fiddle with it some more, but right now it’s not working, so I might be spending Monday doing a full Windows reinstall.

Comcast cable TV lineup for Cambridge Massachusetts

2 Corporation for Public Broadcasting
3 Comcast
4 Viacom
5 Disney
6 Comcast & Hearst Corporation
7 General Electric
8 Public Access
9 Public Access
10 Public Access
11 Corporation for Public Broadcasting
12 AOL Time Warner
13 News Corporation
14 Viacom
15 General Electric
16 Corporation for Public Broadcasting
17 Univision Communications
18 Independent WNDS
19 General Electric
20 Independent WMFP
21 Univision Communications
22 Public Access
23 Independent WYDN
24 Disney
25 Viacom
26 Disney
27 Discovery Communications
28 Viacom
29 Viacom
30 News Corporation
31 AOL Time Warner
32 E.W. Scripps
33 AOL Time Warner
34 Comcast, Disney & Liberty Media
35 Vivendi Universal
36 Disney & Hearst Corporation
37 Discovery Communications
38 Discovery Communications
39 Discovery Communications
40 AOL Time Warner & Liberty Media Group
41 News Corporation
42 AOL Time Warner
43 AOL Time Warner
44 C-SPAN
45 C-SPAN 2
46 General Electric
47 Landmark Communications
48 Disney
49 Disney
50 Disney
51 Boston Red Sox & Boston Bruins
52 News Corporation
53 General Electric & Microsoft
54 Liberty Media
55 Viacom
56 Religious Channel
57 General Electric
58 RTP
59 CableVision & TCI
60 AOL Time Warner
61 Viacom
62 Vivendi Universal
63 Discovery Communications
64 Viacom
65 Liberty Media
66 E.W. Scripps
67 Discovery Communications
68 Sony
70 USA Networks
71 General Electric
72 AOL Time Warner
73 AOL Time Warner
74 AOL Time Warner
75 AOL Time Warner
76 Liberty Media
77 Liberty Media
78 Comcast
79 Viacom
85 AOL Time Warner
95 Public Access
96 Viacom
98 Public Access
99 Viacom
201 Viacom
203 Liberty Media
204 Liberty Media
205 Liberty Media
206 Liberty Media
207 Liberty Media
209 Comcast
210 News International
211 Comcast, Disney & Liberty Media
212 CableVision & TCI
213 AOL Time Warner
216 Oxygen Media
217 Celtic Vision
218 Religious Channel
219 Comcast
220 Viacom
221 Discovery Communications
222 Disney
223 Viacom
224 Viacom
225 Liberty Media
226 Discovery Communications
227 Discovery Communications
229 Religious Channel
230 News International
231 Religious Channel
233 Discovery Communications
235 MBC Middle-east Broadcasting Center
236 Religious Channel
238 Religious Channel
239 E.W. Scripps
240 E.W. Scripps
241 Discovery Communications & BBC
242 Discovery Communications
243 Discovery Communications
244 Paul Allen (Microsoft)
245 Landmark Communications
246 Bloomberg
248 Disney
250 News International
251 Liberty Media
252 Discovery Communications
253 Discovery Communications
255 Global Outdoors
256 News International
270 Disney & Hearst Corporation
271 Cablevision
272 Viacom
273 Viacom
274 Viacom
275 Viacom
276 Viacom
277 Viacom
278 News International
279 Jones Radio Networks
301 AOL Time Warner
302 AOL Time Warner
303 AOL Time Warner
304 AOL Time Warner
305 AOL Time Warner
306 AOL Time Warner
307 AOL Time Warner
321 Liberty Media
322 Liberty Media
323 Liberty Media
324 Liberty Media
325 Liberty Media
326 Liberty Media
341 AOL Time Warner
342 AOL Time Warner
343 AOL Time Warner
344 AOL Time Warner
361 Viacom
362 Viacom
363 Viacom
364 Viacom
365 Viacom
366 Viacom
381 Viacom
382 Viacom
400 Comcast
401 Comcast
402 Comcast
403 Comcast
404 Comcast
405 Comcast
406 Comcast
407 Comcast
408 Comcast
409 Comcast
410 Comcast
411 Comcast
412 Comcast
413 Comcast
414 Comcast
415 Comcast
416 Comcast
417 Comcast
418 Comcast
419 Comcast
420 Comcast
421 Comcast
422 Comcast
423 Comcast
424 Comcast
425 Comcast
426 Comcast
427 Comcast
428 Comcast
429 Comcast
430 Comcast
431 Comcast
432 Comcast
433 Comcast
434 Comcast
435 Playboy
451 Playboy
452 Playboy
453 Playboy
457 Playboy
459 Playboy
701 News International
702 Liberty Media
703 StoryFirst Communications
704 Vila Group
705 General Electric
706 Discovery Networks
707 Liberty Media
708 News International
709 AOL Time Warner
710 Disney
711 Viacom
712 Viacom